In this post, we'll compare two popular project management apps in the industry: JIRA and Trello.
In the process of writing this article Atlassian (which owns JIRA) acquired Trello. Atlassian will be keeping the two separate for the foreseeable future, so the question of JIRA vs. Trello is still very relevant for people who are searching for a PM tool that will solve their needs.
To make sure I give you an unbiased review, I used both JIRA and Trello extensively, started paying for them like a regular customer, and finally have a firm grip of both the pros and cons.
And more importantly, I know the differences between the two and when you should choose one over the other.
If you're unsure about switching from Trello to JIRA this in-depth blog post should help you decide.
Let's jump in and have a look at the differences between JIRA and Trello.
TL;DR Comparison of the two project management tools - JIRA vs Trello
If you're in a hurry, then this quick comparison of JIRA vs Trello should give you a good overview of what each of these apps is good at and how they are different.
|Pricing||Free up to 10 members for cloud version. Standard plan starts at $7/month/member.||Free forever. Standard plan starts at $12.50 per user per month.|
|Hosting||Cloud and on premise||Cloud only|
|Top Features||Kanban Board, Sprints, Access Controls, and Reports||Kanban Boards and Power ups|
|Typical Customer||Mid-market and Enterprise||Freelancers and small businesses|
|Integrations||Massive library of third-party integrations that meets use cases of CRM, test management, code review, and more.||Hundreds of integrations including time tracking apps, Zendesk, Slack, and Salesforce.|
What are the key differences between JIRA software vs Trello?
The key difference between JIRA and Trello is the target audience they go after. JIRA primarily focuses on software developers, engineers, and product managers in medium to large organizations. Trello on the other hand, goes after freelancers, developers, and other contributors in small businesses.
Trello, unlike JIRA, is flexible enough to support other use cases like wedding planning, marketing, and more.
This key difference drives the majority of their decisions in terms of the features they build and how they price their product.
Ultimately, making Trello far easier to get started with. Since JIRA requires you to set it up correctly and go through a steep learning curve, it is a lot harder to onboard your team and get started.
If you don't want to go through JIRA's tedious process to even get started, check out these 13 JIRA alternatives.
Self-hosting vs Cloud in JIRA and Trello
While there are certain advantages to using a cloud-based project management tool, it is understandable that some organizations would want to host and have their data within their network.
JIRA understands this and gives its potential customers both the options you can choose to self-host it or go for their cloud-based option. Trello, on the other hand, does not have a self-hosting option.
So, if you're looking for an issue tracker that lets you self-host, then JIRA is probably your best bet.
JIRA vs Trello: Pricing Info
If you're comparing Trello vs JIRA software in terms of their plans, it's pretty hard to come up with a clear winner today.
Until recently, their plans was one of the bigger differences between JIRA and Trello, since JIRA didn't provide a free plan in their plans. In September 2019, Atlassian, the maker of JIRA software, introduced their free tier. Prior to that, their lowest plan needed you to pay $10 for 10 members.
This, however, only applies if you choose their cloud-based version. If you decide to self-host JIRA by yourself, you will still have to pay $10 for 10 members once.
Trello, on the other hand, has always had a free plan that allows you to create an unlimited number of kanban, tasks, and collaborate with any number of members. However, they do have a restriction on the number of power-ups (their integrations) that you can add. If you want more capabilities on Trello, their “Business Class” plan tier starts at $12.50/member/month.
|JIRA Cloud Pricing||JIRA Self-hosted Pricing||Trello Pricing|
|Free plan for 1 member||Free||$10 one-time payment||Free|
|Standard plan for 1 member||$7 per user per month||$10 one-time payment||$12.50 per month per member|
|Standard plan for 15 users||$105 per month||$3,500 one-time payment||$187.50 per month|
|Standard plan for 25 users||$175 per month||$3,500 one-time payment||$312.50 per month|
|Standard plan for 100 users||$700 per month||$13,300 one-time payment||$1,250 per month|
Task Management and Team Collaboration in JIRA and Trello
Of course, task management and team collaboration are going to be fundamental capabilities you need in project management. When it comes to Trello vs JIRA software though, what they can help you achieve and how they define this varies.
Trello has everything you need when it comes to simple collaboration and task management - creating tasks, setting assignees, adding due dates, notifications, and moving cards from one column to another in a kanban to show progress. If you want to see who is working on what, you can simply use their filters to find this.
JIRA software, on the other hand, looks at task management from the perspective of agile development. It allows you to customize your workflow using the workflow builder and set up rules on how a card should move from one status to another.
You can even go as far as setting up advanced configurations to show only certain work items in certain kanban columns to certain people. Fancy stuff, right?
The downside to this is, if not done right, it can lead to a lot of miscommunication and lost productivity within your team.
JIRA vs Trello: Agile Project Management for Agile Teams
In the last decade, agile and its methodologies have gained a lot of popularity. And for good reasons too! When done properly, agile lets your team build and ship the right software for your customers, and allow them to quickly see value in your product.
JIRA was built specifically to let you and your team follow agile methodologies. Projects in JIRA software support both scrum and kanban. So you can use it either as a scrum tool with scrum board or as a kanban software.
Trello, while known for its simplicity, doesn't support every aspect of agile project management. It lets you to quickly move work around using kanban software tool but projects in Trello does not have dedicated support for scrum teams. This makes using Trello for scrum a difficult task. Some scrum teams, however, workaround by naming columns as a backlog, prioritized, in progress, and done to run sprints.
Reports in JIRA vs Trello
Every team that manages several projects requires the ability to report on their progress, performance, and a host of other metrics. They are not only essential but in crunch times they can help you make key decisions.
JIRA provides a highly configurable dashboard that lets you get insight into any information you want to see about your team. From burn up, burndown, cumulative charts, and many more, JIRA lets you see exactly what you want.
While Trello doesn’t have reports out-of-the-box, it does have some power-ups that you can use to get basic information from your project.
If your team needs agile reports out of the box and you're using Trello, then you might want to consider a Trello alternative.
Integrations in JIRA and Trello
Of course, not all data sits inside your PM tool. You will want to pull in some data from the other tools you use every day, say, your code repository, or Slack into your tasks and projects.
Both Trello and JIRA provide a host of third-party apps that you can connect with. But in terms of sheer quantity, JIRA has over 1000 tools that you can integrate with.
And of course, both tools also provide free access to their public APIs, so you can hit their endpoints and create your own custom workflow.
Wrapping up the comparison of JIRA vs Trello
As you might've noticed, when you take a step back and compare JIRA vs Trello, they are opposite extremes.
While Trello is extremely easy to get started, use, and setup, it doesn't have all the capabilities a growing team would want to streamline their product development process. Its biggest drawback would be its lack of reports and dedicated support to run sprints. This makes it really hard for project managers and leaders to keep track of the progress.
Being a powerful project management tool with exhaustive set of issue tracking and project management features, JIRA surely has the upper hand. This is especially true if you're looking for some complex project management workflows. However, its biggest disadvantage is its steep learning curve and an extremely unfriendly experience that makes developers frustrated and not want to use the tool at all. This creates outdated and stale data in your issue tracker which can lead to teams not being in-sync.
Further Helpful Articles
- 8 best and free project management software tools
- 8 Problems You’ll Face By Using Trello for Agile Web Development
- Trello vs Asana: A detailed comparison
- Trello vs Monday: What's perfect for you?
- Asana vs Trello vs Monday: What's your best bet in 2022?
- Clickup vs Trello: Which is the ideal project management tool?
- Microsoft Planner vs Trello: Which is the ideal project tool for your team?